John G. Avildsen’s 1976 powerhouse film, Rocky, is the most widely-embraced underdog story ever made. The picture enchanted filmgoers and surpassed all expectations regarding box office and critical reception. Winning three Oscars from ten nominations, this was a shining example of a motion picture no one believed in that would become a worldwide sensation. The story of star and screenwriter Sylvester Stallone’s journey to get the film made is even more incredible. Peter Farrelly’s I Play Rocky is the highly entertaining story of Sly’s determination to stay true to his vision and to the character born from his soul.
To capture such a meteoric rise, a film must have the proper cinematic exuberance while keeping the purity of the true tale and the man at its center. Fifty years on, the original Rocky continues to inspire, filling generations of fans with excitement and hope. The heart of the surprising Best Picture winner is in its script; a deeply personal work where every powerful emotion reveals another layer of Sylvester Stallone’s soul. Director Farrelly and screenwriter Peter Gamble understand the assignment. While taking artistic liberties with certain facts, I Play Rocky attains the passion and inspiration found in the little flick about a down on his luck boxer who won the hearts of the world.
The key to the film’s success is found in its star, an incredible Anthony Ippolito. Almost all Stallone impressions are of Rocky Balboa, not the actor who played him. Ippolito has studied his subject and the truth in his performance is the proof. There is respect to the portrayal and the actor is dedicated to capturing every nuance with supreme honesty. There are many instances where Ippolito completely disappears and only Sylvester Stallone remains. This is the kind of precise commitment and total immersion into a character that announces the presence of a great actor. Ladies and gentlemen, I give you Anthony Ippolito.
I Play Rocky begins with Stallone making his way in the cold winter of early 70s New York City. Going to audition after audition, the struggling actor fights an uphill battle to make a living. Finally resorting to starring in a soft-core porn loop and eventually getting evicted from his shabby apartment, Sly realizes he has hit bottom.
Things change when he takes a job in a movie theater and meets Sasha (a very good AnnaSophia Robb). The two fall in love and Sasha gives him the encouragement to write screenplays and pursue his dreams.
The film doesn’t go deep into their relationship, but hits the important (but unfortunately simplistic) beats. While the character actually exists, the Sasha within the film is crafted as a beacon of positive reinforcement. When the chips are down, Sasha is there with rah-rah truisms to help Stallone find his way. It would have been more interesting to examine how the constant poverty affected the stability of Sasha and Sly’s relationship, but that would be a different film. As is, the character and the portrayal fit nicely into director Farrely’s design.
Once Sly and Sasha move to Hollywood, the picture truly catches fire. In only three days, Stallone pounds out the screenplay for Rocky. In the first of many legendary stories about the film’s history, the script makes it to big time producers Irwin Winkler (P.J. Byrne, finally giving a real performance without histrionics) and Robert Chartoff (a perfectly subtle Toby Kebbell). Looking for a hit, they see promise in the work and want to bring Stallone’s script to the screen.
The film has fun with everything that follows. Using his trademark grouchiness, Tracy Letts is perfect as Sandy Maddox, the grumpy studio head who is fed up with too many setbacks for what he perceives as an insignificant “boxing picture.”
As Stallone stands his ground in his desire to play the lead, Maddox keeps yelling about how the actor will never play the role and that the script isn’t even good. The comical payoff comes when scene after scene finds him continually upping the price to buy the script while screaming at his producers that he will never pay a penny more. Over the top? Maybe, but it entertainingly represents Sly’s resolve in the protection of his most personal work.
Casting is always key and Jay Duplass’s stubborn and ill-tempered portrayal of John G. Avildsen is as close to the filmmaker as one can get. On a film set, Avildsen had a reputation for being almost continuously cranky and is remembered as a director who took no-bullshit. Those who worked with him said the man was also encouraging and warm. Through his wonderful performance, Duplass captured such dichotomy.
Certain characters aren’t allowed proper screen time, but many of the actors leave their mark.
Matt Dillon (as Sly’s poppa, Frank Sr.), Stephan James (an uncannily perfect Carl Weathers), and Kiki Seto (eerily capturing Talia Shire’s introverted Adrian) are all great, but they should have found more screen time.
When we get to the actual making of the film, I Play Rocky becomes hit and miss in its depiction of the events. The filmmakers allow viewers to experience the creation of a few big moments (the legendary run up the stairs and the emotional confrontation between Rocky Balboa and Mickey are exhilarating), but the rest of the production gets shortchanged.
We see the beginning of the partnership between Stallone and Weathers, but once filming begins, Weathers gets sidelined. Each moment spent on the set of the 1976 classic is grand entertainment. While the picture moves too quickly through these moments, the enjoyment factor is not dampened, we just wish there could have been more.
Watching Maddox reach comically astronomical levels of stress, seeing the ways Winkler and Chartoff dodged union regulations (and dangerous union leaders), and experiencing the emotional struggle Sylvester Stallone endured while creating Rocky all come together to make one hell of a movie.
Peter Gamble’s screenplay puts a certain polish on Stallone’s true life story. A few scenes (especially his losing and regaining his beloved bullmastiff, Butkus) are reshaped to make certain events go down easier, but each choice works in symmetry with the film’s realistic-yet-sugar-coated.
Peter Farrelly has directed an entertaining version of one of the most legendary rags to riches stories in Hollywood history. The film doesn’t need to go overly serious. There is plenty of drama in Stallone’s journey and it comes through on the screen. That Farrelly crafts his film with a somewhat lighter tone doesn’t diminish the power of Stallone’s struggles and the moving finish where Sylvester Stallone becomes a well-earned star.
I Play Rocky achieves a successful connection with the audience through its heartfelt tribute to a man who refused to let the world break him and to the people who helped assure their movie would capture the hearts of movie lovers everywhere.
For fans of the original Rocky, this will be an exciting, emotional, and inspiring cinematic experience.
I Play Rocky
Written by Peter Gamble
Directed by Peter Farrelly
Starring Anthony Ippolito, AnnaSophia Robb, Toby Kebbell, P.J. Byrne, Jay Duplass, Kiki Seto, Matt Dillon, Stephan James, Tracy Letts
PG-13, 127 Minutes, Amazon MGM Studios